Ben Van Kerkwyk Proves Ancient Technology with a Vase? UnchartedX #ancienttechnology #atlantis

#shorts #short #lostcivilization #ancienthistory #ancientmysteries #vase #egypt #egyptology #alternatehistory #technology #lathe #ancient @UnchartedX

[tomcartwright]

I don’t recall Ben stating the precisely made artifacts had to have been made by computer driven machines. What he did say is these objects are so precise and the tolerances are so small, it is as if they were made by computers.

[Runklsmcdougal]

Why would anyone call Ben a grifter lol. You're off base and taking his content and adding your wrong information for money is a gift

[bobh]

I don’t recall him saying the Egyptians did it… he’s been specific in that the vases seem to predate Egyptian civilization and the tech Egyptians had.

[palmtranconfidential]

Bullshit. Your opinion isn't debunking. You have to prove your point. So a human powered lathe can make vases so exact that we are talking about differences measuring the width of one or two human hairs? You're saying that some of the scandal looks questionable. If you want to have any validity whatsoever you need to say what portion of the scan data seems off and how the scan data seems off. We haven't even come to the subject of what the Vases are made of. We are talking about diorite and granite with inclusions. These are all eight or nine on the mohs scale. How do you propose adding enough weight go to lathe that it can cut through some of the hardest Stone on Earth?

[Elstuderino]

It wasn't Ben that stated they must be designed by a computer or turing machine. It was the guy that investigated it mathematically. The patterns being related to radians and to each other blew his mind. It wasn't the accuracy but the relationship of the mathematics. Chris Dunn also physically inspected the tolerances down to ridiculous levels. Way lower than a basic lathe. Love the channel though. I'm open to being wrong

[tylersouthcott]

Okay so explain why some of the earliest pottery are these granite precise jars and why this ability seemingly disappeared? Why were they not able to continue creating these over the next thousand plus years? Are there any theories as to why there seemed to be a devolution in stone carving and moving including lifting capabilities and precision throughout the multi thousand year Egyptian reign? I haven’t heard a good academic explanation for this. Open to it but “well no one else was around to do it therefore it was them” is not a scientific answer

[philmccracken]

That was a pretty weak attempt to dismiss what Ben has shared with us in regards to these vases. You've got to do better than that!

[andynichols]

Lathe? How do you lathe between two handle nubs??, but still with 1000's of an inch tolerance between those handle nubs, accross the entire surface of the 'od' of the vase, and the vase is the evidence itself, its up to you to work out how... or academia to admit...

[andytraff]

Its not necessarily about the commonality of the artifacts, there are a lot of factors and attributes that add validity to Ben's claims.. some of the materials they are made of have properties that are very unforgiving.. The percision in manufacturing is pretty difficult to hold, without already having precision machines, made up of percision components. The tolerances and consistency that every surface is held to in thickness, or in many cases thinness, an also as in relation to every other surface at every angle and radius.. that is not to say that these vases are uniquely made to this high of a standard for their creation specifically. It may simply be the result of the percision of the machines that they were already using for many other items.. although it may not have been totally necessary to make them that precisely, that is just the level of precision that the machines operated at ..

[tcolley]

Must annoy Ben to have people put words in his mouth & contradict his findings w/o elaborating or providing a shred of evidence. What’s your point? We meant to take your word for it?

[jimmydaniels]

Bullshit. The technology needed to just hold the rock in situ while the bit cut is really advanced. What did they cut it with? How did they achieve the precision?

[matthewreed]

You can't make these with a lathe because of the ears. Seems like evidence of ancient technology.

[kungfumaster]

A powered lathe is high technically. High technically = technology that has a power source to make it work. Instead of hand made. Lost ancient high technology guys scored a point here. This is thier evidence.

[spaceofmind]

You need to listen first. Ben never Said it was the egyptians with Computers :)
However he stated, and had proof, thise were not made by hand snd most likely, also not made by the egyptians.
Get your facts straight...

[seamusinmusic]

Many have pointed out that you've misrepresented the vase research conclusions

It's the engineering math and precision thats astonishing, and the fact that they maintained the tolerances at the parts of the vase where the handles stick out.

[EdGein]

It’s impossible to make them so precise and the walls also be so thin by hand

[DadClwn]

Technology so high they make the most mundane products. Shit don't add up yo.

[leicestersq]

Ben never said that these artefacts were made by any specific tools. What he did do was challenge the theory that they could have been made with the tools that we are told were available at the time.
We can barely make these today, I have seen no evidence that we can replicate them. Some people have said that we can but without doing so. We need to see them make a similar artefact to show what needs to be done.
But what we do know is that someone in the past must have had tech very similar to our own, because without that tech these objects could not be fashioned.

[ferguswatt]

I would like to know if granite vases have ever been turned on hand powered lathes, if so to what tolerances, and what was used as the cutting edge? And if he’s saying this pushes the date of hand powered lathes back over 4000 years, that would mean the hand powered lathe wand invented be fore wheeled carts. Finally, show me a examples where granite vases were turned to just a millimeter thin, translucent thin, while their design incorporates pi, phi, speed of light etc, and how it’s common for a half dozen incredibly specific important numbers happened to all appear together
By accident.

[harmonyandmore]

Either way, the history books need to be rewritten. But the mainstream won't have it.