Can I Win Online in EVERY MLB The Show Game? (19-23)

Today I will be going back in time to try and get an online win in EVERY previous MLB The Show game that still has functioning online play!

Sadly, online servers from before MLB 19 have been shut down so we can't go back any further than that, but MLB 19 is already over 4 years old!

So, can I get a win in ALL of the previous MLB The Show games?

Only one way to find out,

Enjoy!

Join this channel to get access to perks:
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Connect with me:

#MLBTheShow #MLBTheShow23 #DiamondDynasty

[guswetekamp]

I think it's 21 for me. Content was amazing (with really good Topps Now cards which are sorely missed) and the gameplay was really fun until the PCI patch and was still fun enough after that. Pinpoint really changed the game and made pitching an exercise in skill and thought process.

[matrix__bk_]

My favorite MLB game was probably 22. It was the first MLB The Show Game that i got really hooked into:

[YOURBOYSWANNY]

My favorite MLB the Show is probably 22 because they finally made it so if you auto flipped a pack then it wouldn’t flip all the cards if you had a diamond in the pack. I also for some reason really liked the throwing meter because I feel like it was just much easier to use then the new meter. I didn’t like how they took out team affinity but they did add supercharged cards which isn’t a bad trade in my opinion. Another mention is the programs were pretty good especially the All-Star/Home Run Derby program (we don’t talk about the Ken Griffey Jr one) and I liked the rewards. Love you Ance and keep up the great work.

[masonvalente]

My favorite so far I think is 23. I love that day one they had 99s in packs and out in the marketplace unlike all of the other years and I personally love the idea of separate seasons and having to strategize for which cards you use for each season

[citrus_spark]

Amazing video my man! Honestly I might sound crazy but The Show 12 is probably my favorite. Everything felt super clean and it wasn't too easy or too difficult. I absolutely love the newer games, but the older ps3 stuff still takes the cake for me. Probably just my nostalgia bias though lol

[Thatguy_]

My favorite MLB the show is 20 because it was one of the first years that made it easy to have a God squad without spending money or too much stubs

[patrickchristensen]

My favorite the show was probably 21, it was a huge game, there was so much content and many amounts of fun, it was during the end of covid which was fun playing it all day long.

[PNK_Funky]

Honestly for me as a Xbox player my favorite was 22. Got sucked into it through a friend and just had a blast grinding it. Never played online games either unless it was 2’s and we legit never won but it was sometimes the most fun I’ve ever had on video games.

[ogsandiegopadresandcharger]

My favorite mlb the show was for sure 21. I got it the day of launch and I was so pumped and all of my friends were playing it. The vibes were amazing also tatis was on the cover and the padres are my favorite team. The game added so much new amazing features to the franchise, and so many new players with Xbox being able to play now also. The music was amazing, the intro was amazing, and it is overall a very great nostalgic game for me.

[TTVGETUKEDJR]

My favorite MLB the show was ML B 22 bc I’ve only had 19-22 and it’s has nice gameplay and crisp graphics and I loved the diamond dynasty

[THEHOOPER]

My favorite mlb the show game of all time would be mlb the show 22. I loved playing on it. It was so fun. Keep up the work on the vids.

[Mustard_Bomb]

I started with mlb 22 but mlb 23 is already my favorite I love that you can getting 99s on day one the addition of WBC cards and team affinity back. I'm not a huge fan of the sets but that's because I suck but either way absolute masterpiece

[CloroxHimself]

My favorite mlb the show is probably 21 the game play was so enjoyable and just great and for the content they did not miss some cons were the way the pci worked for me I could barely hit with it so I didn’t use it if you don’t agree with me that’s fine but that’s just my opinion and I also loved that they gave the spotlight to Tatis

[Thechannle]

Mine was 21. I really liked the Shohei Ohtani pitcher card.

[dom]

Favorite MLB the Show, to be honest I've only played 19 twice with my friend and 22 and 21 but favorite is 19 because of the events and the players in their prime, like bartolo colon and ichiro. Have a good day Ance

[crackedaf]

Definitely 21 it was my first mlb the show and the parallel system also helped the game so you can have a advantage of grinding using your players. But that is just my preference. Edit: Pinpoint was also pretty good compared to pinpoint now in 23.

[Tyrell]

My fav was 21 in my opinion and im subbed love the content ance

[seanfitzgerald]

The pencil bar in 22 was OP. Hands down.

[aidenhinkle]

My favorite was 23 the show, just I love the way baseball is transforming into and 23 puts personality and great gameplay into a game.

[MultiMaryland]

Mine was definitely 10, pre DD but the RTTS was prime, I sunk so many hours into that.