Yubico Authenticator vs Google Auth vs Twilio Authy - BEST 2FA App in 2024

This episode is sponsored by Yubico!

Becoming a Morse Code Member by checking out the perks linked here!:

💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

SUPPORT MY WORK

💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

FOLLOW THE SOCIALS THINGS

💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

TECH I USE AND RECOMMEND

💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

MY OTHER SHOWS

💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

GET IN TOUCH
Mail ✈

💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

😍 FTC DISCLAIMER 😍
Affiliate links listed above allow me to receive a small commission. Any sponsorships for videos are noted in video and listed in descriptions. Any products provided as gifts are listed above. Thank you for your support!

Comment section code of conduct policy:
Constructive feedback is appreciated, but please leave unproductive, divisive and harmful conversation at the door. Hateful comments are not tolerated, and these kinds of messages will be automatically removed. Thank you for making this community a welcoming experience for all viewers :)

[bigjoegamer]

I've heard that Aegis and 2FAS are good choices.

[BobCollins]

Shannon, I worry about any discussion of digital security that doesn't address open source.
Please don't ignore this elephant in the room.

[AAtta-]

Way to go Shannon! I've been waiting for a showdown with 2FA authenticator's INCLUDING the Yubico authenticator. I use Authy for my home tablet and Yubico for my phone for better security when I'm on the go. I do think you might have mentioned that Yubico authenticator only works with version 5 Yubikey. Love the Yubico authenticator for PURE SECURITY on my phone
Enjoy all your videos!

Much health in the new year.
Anthony

[musicfan]

I choose Authy for convenience with multi-device abilities. Too risky for me to not have a backup in case my phone breaks, gets lost, etc. I think using any 2FA app at all is more/better than your average person does anyway.

[michaelekpo]

Learn a lot about Yubico from watching your videos. You still remain one of the best. Thank you Shannon! Happy New Year!!!

[Scraws]

I love the yubico authenticator but it doesn't hold all my keys. It's has such a low limit.

[cognetic]

Why did you not include Bitwarden or Microsoft Authenticator? Are these not some of the highest market share authenticators?

[Damariobros]

I like Authy for its end-to-end encrypted cloud backups and syncing, using a separate password specifically for said encryption. I can have Authy on any computer or mobile device I want and it'll sync my secrets between all devices. I also appreciate how it has its own PIN lock and doesn't just rely on the device's Lock Screen code, even if you use biometrics it doesn't fall back on the Lock Screen code. Anyone who might happen to have my Lock Screen code can't then get into Authy and get my 2FA codes.

[JAM_]

google authenticator uses an unencrypted HTTP connection, Google said they'd fix it months ago but have yet to do so. Google Authenticator is also closed source, and unlike alternatives, does not let you retrieve keys to use with a separate authenticator.

[JamesDLegan]

Been using Yubico Authenticator for years. Love it and feel secure vs Google and Authy. 👍

[brianalbertosalomonsevilla]

The promo code is not working! neither is the link above it.

[TheOpinionatedYouTuber]

Coupon code does not work for purchasing Yubico😢

[shotbyarian]

tbh for 2FA i don't see why a yubikey makes sense .. anyone can just tap their phone and have my 2FA keys WITH my email .. compared to my phone where i have face unlock and am less likely to lose it compared to an extra device like a yubikey

[lkfng]

I tried the code at checkout and its not valid

[xileets]

Edited to correct some info on the OAuth vuln, but also, to say, great video as always, Shannon!
And to preface the following, I personally do like my yubikeys, I'm just exceedingly sparing in where and how I use them.
Now...
Something's been bugging me about 2fa with security keys and passkeys:
Technically, if you don't need to input a password or OTP, these are NOT 2fa, and the security is still weak. Especially with the recent research reports of reviving dead OAuth session cookies. its important that everyone make sure not to disable passwords if optional when using a yubikey or other security key or passkey. And if password usage does not persist, its just 1FA. 😢

[pedramshirazi]

Hello, is it possible that one certain device be connected to two authenticators (for example yubico and google) silmultaneously?

[aleins]

Hey Shannon 249 p.m. Chicago time September 5th 2024 I've got a question I just got recent access to my Yahoo account and the Yahoo account doesn't use security keys no More I'm not able to set it up on the Yahoo app anymore I need

[jmr]

Twilio drops Authy Desktop app. Too bad that news didn't come out before Shannon made the video.

[TheCrashveride]

What about the vivokey apex? I just got one placed into my forearm right above my wrist. Now I don’t have to worry about losing my yubikey

[jmr]

If you're using standard Android then Google already has all the stuff the app collects. I just wish it was more clear on backups. I accidentally turned that function on then had to turn it off again. I was a bit annoyed because I don't want that feature. I'm perfectly fine manually updating my backup devices.