Are You Scared of Milk White?

Uncover Sheboygan’s legend, Milk White, a sinister specter from an old asylum that preys on children.

CONTENT WARNING: This video contains content that some might find disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.

Emotional/physical distress, blood, discussions around mental health, depiction of injury.

CREATED BY
Ryan Bergara

PRODUCER
Emilie Flynn

DIRECTOR
Mark Celestino

STORY EDITOR
Garrett Werner

ASSISTANT CREATIVE DIRECTOR
Charlie Clay

EDITOR & MOTION GFX
Charlie Clay

HOST
Ryan Bergara Shane Madej

DIRECTOR OF PHOTOGRAPHY
Mark Celestino

CAMERA OPERATOR
Karen Du

SOUND MIXER
Andres Barrientos

ILLUSTRATOR
Rafael Mejia Mollie Ong

PRODUCTION ASSISTANT
Violet Rawlings Brendon Ryu

POST PRODUCTION SUPERVISOR
Sam Young

ASSISTANT EDITOR
Hailey Leonard

HEAD OF DEVELOPMENT
Katie LeBlanc

HEAD OF PRODUCTION
Lizzie Lockard

HEAD OF POST PRODUCTION
Sam Young

EXECUTIVE PRODUCERS
Ryan Bergara Shane Madej Steven Lim

Social:
TikTok @wearewatcher

Business Inquiries:

SFX by Audioblocks
Watcher Logo & Ghost Files Logo Designed by Jennet Liaw

[ValentinesVA]

why is no one talking about how sad this is, bro sacrificed himself for his friends but the whole town thinks he did something awful to those two

[nico_wafer]

it’s funny to imagine Hans somehow knocking himself out and Milk White just left standing there like🧍🏼

[amandahoffman]

WARNING: To anyone who is lactose intolerant, viewer discretion is advised.

[tan_the_man]

this has to be one of my favorite Are You Scared. The twists and turns, initially thinking Hans was betraying them only to realize he'd sacrificed himself for his friends. Uggh. What a story.

[ericab]

These creepypastas could use approximately 175% more anachronistic New York street-tough characters like Jimmy

[strawberrymilkteaa]

“his brains no good, he’s sundowning!” caught me so off guard 😭

[ritsuvampy]

these titles just keep getting stranger

[katlynlacroix]

"Thats illegal!!"
"... yeah. Kidnapping IS illegal"

Omg that cracked me up

[ThrashTrash]

I currently live in Sheboygan and nobody has ever told me the story. I even toured the Asylum, yet it was never mentioned.

[Leafonline]

Shane and Ryan are having too much fun with the “Newyork accent” 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[tayanakanishi]

Shane doing everything to keep Ryan from getting cancelled after he said he was slow😂😂

[fox_n_stlts]

This is my favorite story so far! Well written, good characters, decently creepy. And it had an ending!

[alanbeesby]

“…in Chicago?”

“No, Sheboygan… very big in Sheboygan!” 😂

[bubbe]

19:37 JUSTICE FOR MARK!!!! Shane ran away first at Waverly!
On Buzzfeed Unsolved's Almost 70th Episode special, during Mark's interview segment (7:40), he says that the most scared he had ever been was in Waverly because it was creepy and that was the first time Shane got scared (Shane mentions that everybody was a little terrified there; Ryan adds that Waverly is "comically horrific"). Mark goes on to remember that they were in the body chute hearing weird croak noises, and he was okay thinking it was just a frog. But then, Shane goes "what's that noise?". Mark's camera moves around a bit and the footage gets dark, then the light is back on and you can see Shane running way ahead of Mark (9:02). Mark says, "And if Shane runs and I'm left behind, I'd be terrified because if Shane is afraid, I gotta be", to which Ryan agrees saying that "It must be something real then."
Shane, you absolutely left Mark behind 😭

[chrisbennett]

“And whispered” “AT AMAZON WE HAVE DEALS!” Worst ad timing 😂

[portalchameleon]

As someone from Wisconsin, we have a weird mix of the most normal people combined with unhinged weirdos. My theory is the miserable winter months driving us insane.

[lexiejames]

Me shouting at the tv when you didn’t realise Hans knocked him out to save him! Hans is the only clever one, Hans ain’t slow!!! 😅

[idefine]

As someone who has had several concussions, I hate when characters have "mild concussions" after being unconscious for at least several minutes if not hours. Of course Jimmy doesn't remember anything that happened, he has permanent brain damage.

[sunflowerglo]

"They got in and out in the asylum???😮 I didn't know doordash delivered to those places"

😮‍💨 Lemme tell you... We do.. I once delivered to a place that was essentially a prison for children and I've never felt more downtrodden in my life after leaving somewhere 😢

[nooneasked]

Well, I don't know but I'm lactose intolerant