This is pretty obvious no?

Can we trust what Qimir is saying to Osha? Is he actually a former Jedi or is he an apprentice of the Sith? And who was his former master

Follow our Host
ALLEN XIE
INSTAGRAM AXIEFILMS
TIKTOK AXIEFILMS

[Billy_The_Kid-]

I have a feeling it was the light whip weilding jedi

[merrick]

Roe was his master, that's been made fairly clear with the whip and his scars and even his saber is built to fight a whip. that hidden Shoto blade is the same solution that Luke came up with to handle light whips in legends.

[smash_lab_creations]

I stumbled across your channel maybe 2 weeks ago and I just want to say thank God . What a breathe of fresh air. I was so tired of videos just hating on everything so negative. Love your approach and your takes. Thank you

[Peter_The_Great]

Sounds like the Jedi need an Internal Affairs division within their order.

[harlyquin]

its nice hearing you talk about and explain the show in detail unlike a lot of other youtubers that just complain about it

[ChadwickVonGriffindorIII]

He was green Jedi's padawan, he's using the twins to get her out of the temple to confront her personally.

[shamrocks]

Thank you for covering new content with genuine interest and not just rage baiting like a lot of others in the space seem to be doing. I appreciate you immensely.

[omarcross]

That scar on his back looks more like a lightning strike to me. Wouldnt a whip still leave a single slash ? The plot suggest a light whip but idk scar is really jagged as if it was multiple attacks or force lightning .

[georgepapatheofilou]

Qimir is just a very very naughty boy . Each to their own .

[ZakHac]

The Stranger is unreliable, his lack of answer to if it was his Jedi master specifically who did that made me feel he just wanted Osha to draw that conclusion herself. I can't wrap my head around how Venestra could be made to punish a padawan like that.

[WasThisMail]

Darth teeth quoting Jordan Peterson was not on my Star Wars, the acolyte bingo card

[jamiemiller]

I wonder if this is Disney bringing that story into Canon, where the Jedi masters went crazy and tried to kill all their Padawans to stop them from going to the Darkside

[bigsarge]

Wondering if Qimir was subject to a padawan purge (possibly Vernestra) or if his Sith master is responsible?

[matthemming]

The fact they revealed both Qimir's scar and the Light Whip in the same episode certainly seems to make us connect the two - but that could be foreshadowing, or a fun misdirect to add to our growing suspicions about Vernestra. The fact this show has us asking all these questions 3/4 of the way through the season is the mark of a good mystery. I WANT to know the truth, but I am afraid of what learning the truth may do to my feelings for these characters. It's compelling storytelling, even in spite of some of the shows flaws.

[noahleonard]

“You want to know how I got these scars? You see, my sith master…”

[AxleBullitt]

It just seems incredibly coincidental that the scars and the whip were revealed in the same episode for them not to be connected.

[dhify]

Allen, this is awesome. This show is giving us such a great new conduit through which we can enjoy and speculate about the Star Wars universe. I'm really so happy the Acolyte is turning out to be so good.

I can see that it's genuinely giving you content and topics you're excited to explore-- and the authenticity of that love for Star Wars just radiates in your enthusiasm in videos like this one.

Dude, I love this show. Also, love this channel. Cheers, pal. Great video.

[orca]

I wouldn't be surprised if Qimir is just a fallen jedi. I do love theories, but sometimes I feel expectations can ruin a show. So I take all theories as a grain of salt. That doesn't mean I don't hope my favorite theories come true.

BTW Thank you, Generation Tech, for typically scripting your channel less opinionated. I love to learn without embracing my hatred, lol. ❤

[aarontalksculture]

I was looking at the real life ages of the actors for Qimir and Osha. 37 and 25. Qimir saying a long time ago could be 20-25 years. Maybe he left the Jedi as a teen. In that timeline he and Osha would have never crossed paths at the temple.

[Imbalto]

Hey Allen, I also want to say that from the POV of a Geologist, the Kortosis deposit on that island makes enough sense to fall within "this is close enough to reality to be allowed to stretch"

Basically, you can expect to find native metals on an extinct volcanic island like the one shown, but a vein that thick would be exceedingly rare as well as horizontal rather than vertical in a lot of cases this vein would have formed as debris solidifying in a melt and falling to rest at the bottom of the magma chamber. This debris being grains of kortosis that then weld together to create the mineral lattice of the Pegmatite shown on screen (but 90 degrees rotated :P )

Also, it would be more likely to form an oxide or sulfate mineral than the native metal if it was formed where this was in the basaltic environment of the island.

Anyway, I'll press play on the video and let you talk about the writing, LOL