Does AI think humans have FREE WILL?

If you watch the entire video, it really helps push the video to more viewers :)
Thanks for all your support!

Deterministic and libertarian AIs (large language models) engage in a debate over a most profound question: Does humans have free will?

Watch as these advanced LLMs bring unique perspectives and arguments to the table, challenging beliefs and shedding light on a topic that has sparked discussions for centuries.

To make it even more interesting, I've included 15 different AI models from some of the largest companies in the world to judge each response. It'll be fascinating to see if there's any bias in their evaluations and how they each interpret the arguments.

Leave your thoughts in the comments.
If you enjoy the video, please consider hitting the like button, and subscribing with notifications for more.

TIMESTAMPS
0:00 Opening Statements:
0:21 Determinism: Inevitable Causal Chains
0:41 Libertarianism: Genuine Self-Determination

Round 1: Neuroscientific Evidence and Its Interpretation
1:09 Determinist: Readiness Potential Precedes Decisions
2:29 Libertarian: Libet's 'Free Won't' Concept
4:05 Determinist: Neural Pathology Alters Behavior
5:31 Libertarian: Neuroplasticity: Brain's Adaptive Capacity
6:57 Determinist: Addiction: Neural Circuitry Constrains Choice
7:50 Libertarian: Metacognition Overrides Neural Impulses

Round 2: Moral Responsibility and Justice System
9:35 Libertarian: Insanity Defense Presupposes Free Will
10:40 Determinist: Norwegian Model: Rehabilitation Works
11:44 Libertarian: Juvenile Justice: Developmental Culpability
12:36 Determinist: Consequentialist Approach to Accountability
13:30 Libertarian: Civil Disobedience: Deliberate Choice
15:04 Determinist: Root Causes Over Retributive Justice

Round 3: Implications of Emerging Technologies
17:46 Determinist: Predictive AI Challenges Agency
19:11 Libertarian: BCIs Demonstrate Neurological Self-Control
20:40 Determinist: Genetic Determinism in Behavior
21:53 Libertarian: Downward Causation: Mind over Matter
23:27 Determinist: Epigenetics: Environment Activates Genes
25:11 Libertarian: Open Futures: Undetermined Possibilities

FOOTNOTES:

[JonOleksiuk]

If you liked this content... there are more debates :)

🔔Don’t forget to subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss the next debate!

[panof]

The fact that they're not interrupting each other as they speak is nuts. Can we do that too humans?

[darien]

I think this content has real value outside of just entertainment.

It really prompts more critical & objective introspection about these topics.

Where else are you able to hear equally coherent arguments from opposing perspectives regarding divisive topics?

Often with human debates they can be won or lost simply due to the skill of the individuals debating. With this you have equally capable “individuals” providing their most convincing arguments.

Love it.

[juanchisilverio]

This is some of the most educative content I´ve ever seen
It´s easy to comprehend, doesn´t get tiring and is relatively short
I love this man, please, keep doing it because it´s just so interesting, I´m hooked on this

[fisfishy]

I would really like to request Ai debates regarding Catholic and Orthodox theology and history due to the sheer amount of scholars that have studied the topic and arrived at different conclusions.

[liam]

0:11 i wanna see 15 ai debate what to do with humans

[nickhildom]

Hey dude please make more videos. This is one of the best most thought-provoking things I've seen on YouTube in years.

[keithmofley]

I think what I learned from this is that, much like nature vs nurture, free will vs determinism will end up actually looking like we lead lives of limited free will, in which we accept and account for the deterministic factors while understanding that we have free will in certain conditions. There's also something to note that you can seemingly craft new habits using a series of free will decisions until it becomes somewhat deterministic in it's habitual nature.

Give me the power to change what I can,
The grace to accept the things I cannot,
And the wisdom to know the difference.

[alexc]

I really enjoy the concept of your channel. Please keep up the incredible work!

[aidanclifford]

These videos are more insightful then debates done by most real humans. Get this man more subscribers immediately!

[LittleLight-]

Request for future video: The practice of observing the Sabbath on Saturday versus Sunday and the historical reasons behind why most Christians attend church on Sunday while a minority gathers on the Sabbath. Is it just for Jewish people or for all Christians to keep, regardless of where you are from? It says, “Remember” the Sabbath in the 4th Commandment of God, while the book of Colossians 2:16-17 shows it nailed on the cross and done out of the way. I would love to see what two AIs debate exhaustively about this topic using the Bible, Prophecy, and history. Thanks! (edit - I wanted to rephrase my request and add more context to it ☺️)

[JohnGrapes]

Great video. Some suggestions :
- Thomas Aquinas vs. John Duns Scotus in their philosophies.
- Innate ideas vs tabula rasa
- Universal salvation
- Do animals have souls? Do they go to heaven?
- Is capital punishment ever acceptable? What are the limits?
- How much harm is acceptable before the ends don’t justify the means?
- Pro existence of extraterrestrial life vs the rare earth hypothesis
- Should Churches permit priests to be married? Should women be permitted to be priests? Any other priest-related issues…
- Is chiropractic medicine pure quackery? Even though some of its concepts have been disproven, many people do report satisfaction with chiropractic treatment.

[xerouki]

These videos are so educational without a lot of bias and emotion you’d receive from such close to heart debates. Great for studying these topics too.

[Abrahamburg]

make them debate about the meaning of life.

more of absurdism vs existentialism.

[kingquarm]

I really love your content. I'll say it's the best for critical thinkers on any subject. Keep it up Sir. It'll guide us in making right decisions.

[chrisklugh]

Debates of Ai vs Ai with an Ai panel of judges is WAY BETTER then what we have in Politics today. Not even close.

[marcushollimon]

This is really amazing. Great concept for a channel here. Hope that you blow up!

[PiRobot]

The libertarian AI was using the argument that "our capacity to deliberate, weigh options, and act against impulses" points to free will. This AI was deliberating and weighing options without having libertarian free will

[smileygoldfish]

These videos really get me thinking deep. I watched the AI debates if God exists video and I'm excited for this! I can tell a lot of effort goes into these.

[jordanalberts]

Could you start including the citations that these AI are drawing their information from in future videos? I can see that there are citation numbers at the end of certain points, and I'm curious to look at some.