Popular Jersey Mike's Menu Items Ranked Worst To Best

Jersey Mike’s has been making fresh sandwiches since before it was even Jersey Mike’s. Founded in 1956 as Mike's Submarines, it wasn’t until current CEO Peter Cancro bought the Point Pleasant Beach sandwich shop in 1975 that it started to become the sub shop we know and love today. Now, with nearly 2000 locations and near endless sandwich combinations, there’s a lot to love about Jersey Mike’s.

But which menu item is the best menu item? Don’t worry — we’ve taken on the task of trying each of Jersey Mike’s best selling offerings and ranking them for you. These are the most popular Jersey Mike's menu items ranked worst to best.

#JerseyMikes #Menu #Sandwiches

Tuna Fish | 0:00
Bacon Ranch Chicken Cheese Steak | 0:53
Portabella Chicken Cheese Steak | 1:29
Ham and Provolone | 2:01
Brownie | 2:35
The Veggie | 3:21
Roast Beef and Provolone | 3:48
BLT | 4:20
Jersey Shore's Favorite | 4:49
California Chicken Cheese Steak | 5:21
Club Supreme | 5:51
Stickball Special | 6:28
Mike's Famous Philly | 6:59
Portabella Cheese Steak | 7:45
The Original Italian | 8:22
Cancro Special | 8:51
Big Kahuna Cheese Steak | 9:20
Club Sub | 9:57
Chipotle Chicken Cheese Steak | 10:30
Buffalo Chicken Cheese Steak | 11:07
Grilled Portabella Mushroom and Swiss | 11:29
The Number Four | 12:01

[MashedFood]

What's your go-to order from Jersey Mike's?

[glennzanotti]

The Original Italian dressed 'Mike's Way" is my go-to sandwich. It is pretty darn close to a real South Jersey Hoagie.

[pizzaman]

The Club Supreme takes so good, especially when you add hot peppers and spicy mustard!! The roast beef is so much better than any other sub the way, is it just me, or does anyone think the narrator is a bit too critical about a majority of Jersey Mike's menu?

[Art_V]

90% of my visits to Jersey Mike’s is for a Tuna Mike’s way with bacon, its truly one of the best tuna sandwiches anywhere, and adding the lettuce, tomatoes, bacon and vinegar is truly what makes it.The brownie is also a must do.

[julianhudson]

I JUST had Jersey Mike's for the FIRST time on Thursday afternoon! I had the Club Supreme with Italian dressing instead of mayo. It was awesome!! I miss it already!! :)

[Reality_Filter]

So hard to get a really tasty, really fresh, with high quality meats in an Italian sub. The Original Italian #13, Mike's way is simply amazing. Only way it would be better was if there was an Italian bakery next door pumping out bread every hour...

[queenb]

They are nuts..the brownie is the bomb! Made by Harry abd David I believe. I love Jersey Mikes..it beats any other sub shop I have been to. Living in Florida niw they love the Publix subs...blah l take JM any day

[Lynn]

So far I've only had the turkey sub from Jersey Mike's and it was amazing.

"You can make it at home." You can, but sometimes you just want your favorite basic thing made for you right in front of you and all nicely wrapped up to go.

[michellemeyer]

I grew up in Chicago in a huge Italian neighborhood....believe me "Jersey Mike's" is legit and consistent and now that I don't live in Chicagoland area I truly appreciate this place. It's delicious!!!

[donkensler]

I grew up in South Jersey, not too far from Philly, and I grew up on hoagies and cheesesteaks, so when Jersey Mike's opened up near me here in Michigan I had to try it out. Of course I had to get a cheesesteak and an Italian, and I thought both were top notch, primarily because of the rolls, which are as close as I've had to the rolls of my youth since I left Jersey. Yes, their Italian meats are awesome, and the cheesesteaks are the real thing. One of these days I have to ask to customize my cheesesteak with tomato and lettuce, which makes it a cheesesteak hoagie.

Also on my favorites list nearby me is DiBella's. They do a really good cheesesteak and a buffalo chicken, and they have a meatball sub that is freakin awesome. Mike's used to have a really good meatball sub but discontinued it :(

[klcheetah]

I used to go to the Jersey Mikes in Freehold and Point Pleasant, NJ before they became a national chain. These new stores do not even begin to compare to the original.

[nans]

#13 original Italian Mike's way with pickles. I get the juice on the side because we usually buy it a couple hours before eating it. Only put on when ready to eat. No soggy roll. I agree with big Kahuna. It's really good. When I want a hot sandwich, I order it. I do substitute banana peppers for the jalapeños.

[speedfiend]

You left out their AMAZING Large Chocolate Chip Cookies! 😞 Pro tip: Take the cookie home and pop it in the oven at 350 degrees for about 10 mins and serve with a glass of milk. 🤤🍪🥛

[ayosgsauce]

Automatically hit Like because of the labeled Timestamp Chapters.

[tyrionlannister]

First time I ever went to jersey mikes and got their club supreme, the person making it asked “do you want it Mikes way?” I saw the sign saying “try it Mikes way!” On the glass window and said sure!
He then grabbed the oil n vinegar and Drenched the lettuce, onions n tomato on my sandwich, my Gut reaction was “Oh dear lord he just ruined my entire sandwich, oh hell..”
well to my delight it didn’t make the bread soggy but soaked into the toppings and made the entire sandwich amazing.

Always get it mikes way, I sometimes add jalapeños.

[edgerj]

#13 Mike’s way with extra juice is the number 1 all day any day.

[TheRocketMouse]

I'm shocked that turkey and provolone didn't make the list. In my opinion, that's the best sub on the menu.

[ajonesa]

Weak!!! The 13 is clearly the best sandwich there!!!

[TnseWlms]

I once saw a Jersey Mike's shop on a downtown street in California. The window was plastered with big signs saying "Cash Only, " "No Public Restroom, " "No Bus Change, " "No Loitering" and "Not a Walkthrough." I couldn't decide whether this franchise owner didn't know how to run a business, or wanted to make the customers think they were in New Jersey.

[danb]

You're nuts!
Celery, pepper and Mayo is ALL a tuna sandwich needs!