Is It Bad to Have Number as Object Keys in JavaScript?

Discover if using `number` as keys in JavaScript objects is a good practice or not, along with the implications and alternatives.
---

Visit these links for original content and any more details, such as alternate solutions, latest updates/developments on topic, comments, revision history etc. For example, the original title of the Question was: Is it bad to have "number" as object keys?

If anything seems off to you, please feel free to write me at vlogize [AT] gmail [DOT] com.
---
Is It Bad to Have Number as Object Keys in JavaScript?

In the realm of web development, especially with JavaScript, you often encounter various patterns and practices that can lead to confusion. One such quandary is whether it's acceptable to use number as keys in an object. While there are opinions and debates within the developer community, let’s dissect this topic to clarify any uncertainties you may have.

The Problem

You might come across JavaScript objects that look something like this:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

In this example, numeric keys are being used directly in an object. This raises an important question: Is this a good practice? Many developers argue that it isn't ideal because it diverges from the expected usage of objects in JavaScript. So, what’s the verdict?

The Answer: Yes, It’s Legal but Caution is Advised

Key Takeaways

Yes, it's legal: Using numbers as keys in an object is permissible in JavaScript and TypeScript. Objects accept any string or symbol as key, and when you use numbers, they are converted to strings.

Potential Misleading Nature: While it does work technically, using numeric keys can lead to confusion for other developers. They might expect behaviors consistent with arrays, such as continuous numeric indexing (e.g., 0, 1, 2) and orderly iteration. However, this is not guaranteed with objects.

Difference from Arrays: Unlike arrays, which enforce incremental indices starting from 0, objects do not maintain a specific sequence. This can be misleading in scenarios where developers expect a direct relationship between keys.

Recommendations

If you are considering using numeric keys for your objects, here are some points to keep in mind:

Maintainability: Using numeric keys can result in code that is difficult to understand and maintain. Other developers might be unsure about the order and context of these keys.

Use of Arrays: If the intention is to mimic an array-like structure, it's advisable to simply use an actual array. You can implement logic to handle indexes starting at 1 if required, which retains clarity while allowing you access to array methods like length, sort, and find.

Alternative Approaches

If you're trying to achieve specific behaviors with numbered indices, consider these alternatives:

Standard Arrays: Use regular arrays and simply adjust your code to handle index offsets if needed.

Maps: If you require key-value pairs where keys are not strings, consider using the Map object. This structure allows for any type of key and preserves the order of entries.

Conclusion

In summary, while it's technically legal to use numbers as object keys, it's not necessarily a best practice. The potential for confusion, particularly for other developers who might work with your code, makes it advisable to stick to conventions that maintain clarity. By using arrays or maps where appropriate, you can harness the full set of capabilities JavaScript offers, all while keeping your code easy to read and maintain.

Proceed with caution and make informed decisions about your key types to foster better collaboration and understanding in your development projects.