What are the implications of #Ukraine damaging the NIP-16 site in Crimea with #atacms ?

preview_player
Показать описание
Ukraine struck the NIP-16 Deep Space Communications site in Yevpatoria, Crimea.
As per reports, the strikes were carried out by U.S. made Army Tactical Missile System (ATACMS)

The Yevpatoria Center for Deep Space Communications supports both manned and unmanned space missions and has two sites both of which seem to have been hit.

Satellite images indicate the presence of several scorch marks.
Footage circulating on social media showed massive fires, following the strikes.

In this video, Defense Updates analyzes what are the implications of Ukraine damaging the NIP-16 site in Crimea with ATACMS?

#defenseupdates #atacms #ukrainerussiawar

Chapters:
00:11 INTRODUCTION
01:38 NIP-16 DEEP SPACE COMMUNICATIONS
04:26 ATACMS
06:30 TARGETING RUSSIAN KEY ASSETS
07:37 ANALYSIS

"Giant Wyrm" Kevin MacLeod (Licensed under Creative Commons)
Рекомендации по теме
Комментарии
Автор

NIP 16 was designed as long range communication hub. Russia likely repurposed it for communication with its forces across Ukraine. Ukraine constant attacks on Crimean targets is making clear how much Russia depends on Crimea and Ukraine 's goal of strategically cutting Crimea out of the picture completely

verdebusterAP
Автор

Oooh! They can talk to spacecraft that far away? Wow!
So what, we can talk to Voyager in interstellar space. Russia is a joke, with a nuclear punchline.

Confessor
Автор

This was disappointing. What little discussion there was of the "implications" for damaging the NIP-16, made generous use of "may", "could" and "maybe", so as to impart little meaning. Personally, I think the attack on NP-16 could result in serious damage to the green cheese making up the Moon, may limit Russia's ability to impede the cows jumping over the Moon, and maybe even result in a tax increase. :)

jameswalker
Автор

Since NIP-16 is west of Baikonur it would not be in position to communicate with a vessel while it ascends to orbit, and it is likely not far enough west to be used during the de-orbit burn of a Soyuz, which I believe takes place far over the Atlantic. I'm not sure if Soyuz can communicate directly with the US TDRSS satellite constellation, but it seems likely they can, in which case communications with crewed space missions is unlikely to be seriously affected.
"Degrading communications with space assets" is probably a good way to put it, since it's likely not positioned correctly to communicate with a crewed spacecraft at an important milestone during a mission.
I'd be surprised if this was considered significant enough for Ukraine to devote assets for this mission. NIP-16 is probably used as a communications hub for the Russian military and the goal was to degrade their military communications.

JohnWilliamNowak
Автор

Nice e nice gotti Bing Bong ya so they thought SIKE

richvasquez
Автор

It's just ATACMS NOT Army-TACMS. You've been getting this wrong for years. It's annoyeing.

bbmw
Автор

how does this affect situation at after all, everything is very bad at front The DS military analytical resource working for the GUR also published a new map at night, where the Russian Armed Forces broke through from the south, getting closer to the center of New York. And the neighboring village of Yuryevka has almost come under the control of the Russians, a sweep is underway.
The Russians also entered into Friendship and gained a foothold on the outskirts.
The assault on Yuzhny (Pivdennoye) continues, in the area of which the Russians occupied the dump of the Severnaya mine and knocked the APU out of position, advancing along the streets of Kaluzhskaya, Moskovskaya and Chernyshevsky.
The assault on Kirovo (Severny/ Pivnichny) also does not stop, the AFU has lost a number of strong points. The Russians are moving through the streets from the east and south.

arlokino
Автор

Oh, what a waste, world scintice could lost one very important station for outer space studies. I don't know but it's better not to destroy those progress for man kind. 😕😕.

wolfwolf
Автор

Please read RUSSIA'S NUCLEAR DOCTRINE.

rogersmith
Автор

Ukraine is losing this war beside they are causing minor damage in Russia.

rhodium
Автор

Prigo told the truth about the false justifications for the invasion stay strong Ukraine 🇺🇦

markcepeda
Автор

no. Russia prior to 2014 had 3 sites like this in addition to numerous other smaller elements of ground control network. Anexation of Crimea did not add anything cirtical to it, and destruction of NIP-16 makes no difference for any Russian space capabilities that deteriorate independently becuase of sanctions and war costs, lack of management, corruption and lack of engineers. Nothing had changed. In additon Russia has complete coverage of near Earth Space thanks to its antiballistic radar systems put on ground. Stop spewing nonsense. In order for it to be a hit of this importance one of the 3 other facilites would have to be destroyed deep inside Russia. That was attack of opportunity, it is a small hit, potentially more important for war theater than for space due to the fact that NIP-16 also can detect things in the air. The last conclusions-psychology + prospect of holding Crimea not attainable for Russia is true goal and purpose. Ukrainians are regularly conducting very interesting tactical operations targeting various radars and other expensive equipment there. So THIS is their goal, not what video concentrates on which is as I said nonsense.

Zarrov
Автор

So in other words Ukraine wasted ATACMS missiles hitting stuff with no military significance.

BobWidlefish