How to Solve the #VALUE Error When Using a VBA Function in Excel

Discover the solution to the common `#VALUE` error encountered when using VBA arrays in Excel, and find out how to effectively use the `extractcolumn` function.
---

Visit these links for original content and any more details, such as alternate solutions, comments, revision history etc. For example, the original title of the Question was: VBA function works within a sub procedure but not on the excel worksheet: "value" error. Probably an issue with one argument being an array

If anything seems off to you, please feel free to write me at vlogize [AT] gmail [DOT] com.
---
Understanding the #VALUE Error in Excel VBA Functions

If you have been working with VBA (Visual Basic for Applications) in Excel, you may have come across the frustrating #VALUE error when trying to use a function on your worksheet. This commonly occurs when your function is designed to work with arrays, and might be due to how the function's arguments are configured. In this guide, we will break down a typical issue related to this error and offer a practical solution.

The Problem: Function Works in Sub Procedure but Not on Excel Worksheet

You might have experienced this scenario: You have written a function that is supposed to extract a specific column from a two-dimensional array. The function works perfectly within a sub routine but returns a #VALUE error when used directly in an Excel worksheet. The given function (with intentions of being efficient) is as follows:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

The underlying issue is that the function expects an array as input, rather than a direct range from Excel.

Key Points to Note

When you declare your VBA argument as an array (i.e., mat() As Variant), the function must be called with an array argument.

Directly referencing a range (like A5:C7) will not work unless it is properly converted to an array format that VBA understands.

Exploring the Solution

To resolve this issue effectively while maintaining efficiency, consider using one of the following approaches:

Option 1: Pass Array with Proper Syntax

If you want to use your function in Excel, ensure that you pass the range in a compatible way. You can convert a range to an array by using:

=extractcolumn(A5:C7, 2) should be modified to:

=extractcolumn(+A5:C7, 2)

=extractcolumn(--A5:C7, 2)

=extractcolumn(A5:C7&"")

By prefixing the range with +, --, or concatenating it with an empty string "", you force Excel to treat the range as an array.

Option 2: Modify the Function to Work with Ranges

Alternatively, you can rewrite your function to work directly with a range, which will allow it to be used seamlessly in the worksheet:

[[See Video to Reveal this Text or Code Snippet]]

Benefits

Modifying the function as shown above can improve compatibility and reduce the number of lines of code needed, as you do not have to convert the range to an array in advance.

Conclusion

The #VALUE error can be a common stumbling block when using VBA functions in Excel worksheets, especially when working with arrays. By adjusting how you reference your data or changing your function to accept a range, you can efficiently manipulate your data while avoiding these frustrating errors.

If you have any further questions or need clarification on this topic, feel free to reach out!