Is the Vintage Toy Market OVER!?

Is the Vintage Toy Market OVER!?
LONGER WEEKLY EPISODES HERE:
Join this channel to get access to perks:
COME TO OUR SHOW! BUY TICKETS TODAY!
REP OUR MERCH!

Transformers Trade Gone Wrong! Collector Wants $7,000, Ryan Thinks They're Worth $1,500

In this episode of the Toy Federation YouTube channel, we dive into the world of vintage Transformers toys! A passionate collector visits the Toy Federation store with a collection of Transformers figures he hopes to trade for a whopping $7,000. But there’s a twist—Ryan, the owner and vintage toy expert, values the collection at only $1,500. This leads to a heated yet respectful negotiation that offers a fascinating look at the art of trading vintage toys.

What’s in the Collection?
The collector’s lot is impressive, with a mix of G1 (Generation 1) Transformers, iconic figures like Optimus Prime and Megatron, and some lesser-known Autobots and Decepticons. While the toys look great at first glance, Ryan quickly notices some issues that impact their value. Missing accessories, wear and tear, and incomplete sets all play a role in his assessment.

The Valuation Process
Ryan breaks down the value of each item, explaining how rarity, condition, and completeness influence his appraisal. For Transformers fans and collectors alike, this segment is an invaluable lesson in understanding the real worth of vintage toys. Whether you’re new to collecting or a seasoned pro, you’ll gain insights into how toy store owners determine value and why emotional attachment doesn’t always translate to higher prices.

Tense Negotiations
The discussion heats up as the collector defends his asking price, citing recent online sales and his personal investment in the toys. Ryan counters with cold, hard facts, showing comparable sales and emphasizing the realities of retail pricing. Will they find common ground, or will the deal fall through?

Educational and Entertaining
This episode isn’t just about the trade—it’s a deep dive into the fascinating world of Transformers collecting. Ryan shares tips on:

How to identify authentic vintage Transformers
The importance of box and accessory completeness
What makes certain Transformers worth thousands while others only fetch a few hundred
Behind the Scenes at Toy Federation
As always, we bring you behind the scenes at Toy Federation, one of the Southeast’s premier vintage toy stores. Watch as Ryan and the team evaluate toys, interact with collectors, and share their expertise on everything from Transformers to Star Wars, G.I. Joe, and beyond.

Get Involved!
We want to hear from you! What do YOU think about the collector’s Transformers? Was his asking price fair, or was Ryan’s valuation spot on? Let us know in the comments. Plus, tell us about your favorite Transformers figure—do you own any rare pieces, or are you hunting for a specific Autobot or Decepticon?

Subscribe for More Vintage Toy Content
If you love vintage toys, trading stories, and behind-the-scenes action, make sure to like, comment, and subscribe to the Toy Federation YouTube channel. We post weekly videos showcasing incredible toys, expert appraisals, and the collector community.

Transformers fans, vintage toy collectors, and negotiation enthusiasts alike won’t want to miss this thrilling episode! Dive into the fascinating world of vintage toys, where every trade tells a story. Autobots, roll out! 🚛💨

[kingfluffy]

I will never understand after all of the years of Ebay, how people do not understand the difference between listed vs. sold prices.

[bootlegcraig]

If customers want top dollar for their stuff, then they need to create an ebay account and sell it themselves. Period.

[danedwards]

This is why I changed my retail store business plan. All that inventory sitting on shelves growing mold. It's more like a collection than a business. I only offer walk in sellers 30% of ebay sold because I don't need their poorly chosen purchases sitting on my shelves for years. Now when I buy items I put a notice on social media to the locals letting them know they have a week to come in and buy or the items go on ebay auction no reserve starting at 25% above what I paid. Now my store has amazing turnover and I don't have to worry about paying the rent.

[cerd]

I don’t sell to dealers because I know I lose 50% off the top. You need to know how the system works. Don’t go to retail, and expect them to give you retail…come on.

[LeutyMatt]

I love your content and the fact that I was born deaf and can follow along to the subtitles and still enjoy the nostalgia (im 47) is fantastic.

[tonymedina]

Sadly, people like us who grew up with this toys and we have a sentimental value towards this plastic figures, we are getting older and are passing away. I know I will not make my money back on trying to compete my collection but I will always have the satisfaction that I grew up in the era of the best toys of the 80s.

[luisquintana]

I look at this video and all I can think is “ I have to stop wasting my money and buying toys”.

[jmsparger]

Off topic...
Thank you for restoring the format. As a 60 year old collector this was/is my new Saturday morning cartoons. I get lost, relaxed, entertained, and in a good mood after.

[PunLV]

Ryan is too nice. Wish people understood the difference between eBay asking vs sold. Plus how much eBay takes when you sell something

[AristotleOfGreece]

"If you're not in a hurry you don't have to sell it to me" absolutely nailed it. If you want top dollar sell individual pieces on your own. If you wanna move a lot of stuff really quick sell it as a lot or sell it to a store but know you are essentially "paying a premium" (i.e. losing profit) for the convenience of moving a whole bunch at once.

[CARDSxx]

Poor guy told his girl he was rich😂 I’m feeling the second hand embarrassment

[ryancreery]

to everyone:
nobody is going to get rich in the toy business, if its not fun anymore, you are in the wrong hobby-

[anthonyspats]

This guy is shooting for the stars, no way it’s worth what he wants. The fact you went up a few hundred shows how honest you are with your clients . Let him sell on his own.

[scottcaudill]

More than fair. Went from $1300 to $1700. Not making much on that deal.

[cottonmouth]

Wow. I know nothing about toys. But I can appreciate how much knowledge it probably requires to pick up a random toy from the 90s a customer brings in, and to be able to identify each piece and its condition

[Justrandomvideos-]

He needs to start selling all those toys in shop before running out of space 😂😂

[ianrotten]

I was into this for about a decade. Needless to say, I sold everything and got out on top. I'd never get back into this kind of thing these days considering on how insane the whole vintage market has become.

[Bran-EX]

Remember that time dude came in with those Transformers? "But then he said $6000 or $7000!!!" 🤣😂.

[haroldmclean]

Because the Seller bought High, doesn't mean that the Buyer has to too

[Woodman.]

All Vintage is over, .. youth doesn’t care