Tudor Pelagos Vs Omega Seamaster

These are probably the best dive watches under £5000.

Which dive watch is best, Tudor Pelagos or the Omega Seamaster 300m (SMP).
These are the best dive watches or desk divers.

INSTAGRAM
@barkandjack

GEAR

#Tudor #Omega #BarkAndJack
bark and jack,tudor,omega seamaster,barkandjack,seamaster,omega,watch review,omega review,pelagos vs seamaster,tudor pelagos,watches,pelagos,watch,best dive watch under 5000,omega vs rolex,omega vs tudor,white dial omega seamaster,watch collection,tgv,diver,teddy baldassarre reviews,rolex review,best dive watches,best dive watches under 10000,rolex,seiko,rolex submariner,breitling,divers,submariner,daytona,wristwatch,omega seamaster 300m,review,Automatic

[francos]

As consumers, we should be thankful to have excellent watches like these that are available.

[hypnotoads]

I’d like to correct you on just one point if I may. I think we do need watches that slide under the cuff - if they don’t how else can they perform the dual function of a) being able to wear a beautiful new watch and b) hiding it from the wife 🤔

[frohnnielsen]

I enjoyed the comparison. I bought the Pelegos LHD, because I’m a lefty—at least that’s how I rationalized it. It’s “look” is entirely different than the blue one, and just instantly resonated with me. It’s my “daily driver” for 1.5 years now, and it still brings me enormous pleasure.

[anthonystevens]

Great constructive review Adrian. I've tried both watches at an AD (the pelagos was an LHD in black) and I really like the Pelagos in blue from photographs but prefer the LHD version in black and for what it is, a tool watch it does all that I'd want. No pizzazz it just does the job incredibly well. The bracelet is incredibly functional and easy to use for us mere mortals as well. The lume of the hands and ceramic bezel it incredible . The in house movement with 70 hours reserve and COSC certification at the price is a real plus also. This watch does what it needs to do for a purpose and it does it really well.

The Omega is something different though, that white dial with the waves is something that you really need to see in the flesh, it's simply a work of art in different lighting conditions, the black skeleton hands, the black ceramic bezel with white inlay is just gorgeous in my humble opinion. The bracelet with the on the fly push to fit is great as well. The Omega is the more versatile watch given the case and lug shape along with that dial with the date at 6. The tooth paste cap at 10 is easily forgotten on the wrist. It;'s a heritage thing at the end of the day.

In summary, if you need a watch to do the job the Pelagos would take my hard earned cash. But if you want something more versatile and have the extra money the Omega would be the one to shrink my bank account. Given a choice I'd want both.

[scott]

The Omega is a real looker. The dial sometimes is shiny, sometimes not. The ceramic details on the bezel really pop, even better than the sub and are flush which is a real bonus. Just an all around more fun watch to look at in different lighting conditions. Let’s face it, we all love to look at our watches and on the front and back, the Omega is just better looking.

[mattmcd]

I’ve owned a Pelagos and currently have the black dialed Seamaster. I love both, but the Omega is technically on another level with the coax. I agree that Tudor has the better bracelet, but the Omega is still quite good in that regard. I think the Omega is significantly more wearable and flexible. Also, I think you may have missed a trick by not showing either on their respective rubber straps. The Omega is KILLER on its OEM rubber

[ErikL]

Somebody called the Pelagos a “poker chip” and that kinda ruined it for me. 😂

[warrbandit]

I’m a simple man. I like watches, I like coffee and if I see a Bark and Jack video I click play.

[timeresonance]

I have Pelagos from 30.12.2020. I was heading for North Flag, but I tried Pelagos and Black Bay P01. I was surprised at how light Pelagos was, despite his size. I haven't had a titanium watch before. Pelagos is not my type of watch, but something happened. I liked it and with each passing day I like it more and more. This is not a watch like love at first sight. However, it is its simplicity, which you can not get enough of, that makes you like it more and more. It is obvious that it is made according to all the rules of perceptions - reduce to the maximum. What is most impressive, however, is the accuracy of the movement - in the first month it worked with an accuracy of -1.4 seconds. per day. Now he is 5.5 seconds behind for 16 days, regardless of the position in which he lies. Unbelievable.

[carzakone]

I would go for Pelagos, specially the LHD, the escape knob of Seamaster is just useless and odd looking, also prefer the oyster case and bracelet of Tudor, so hot looking!

[denniskai]

I own the blue Pelagos -- There is something about the stark simplicity and contrast of the dial and bezel. It also feels rugged and reliable. It's my go-to tool watch. It also keeps miraculously impeccable time. That said, I do admit to checking out the white seamaster videos. I love everything about it - except that helium escape valve at the 10 o'clock position. It's the one visual feature that I can't get past. Also - like you, I'm not a fan of the non-tapering braclet. Cheers - Dennis

[Jckendall]

I feel like I say this every video Adrian but seriously dude your production quality and B roll are top notch

[authorjohnwquinn]

I'd go with a white Seamaster with a black rubber strap. Love that look.

[JasonTheWatchGuy]

After reviewing the Seamaster it has become a favourite of mine. The quality that is built into that watch truly is something else. Especially when you tend to concentrate of more affordable watches.

[WatchWithUs]

There’s such a tool appeal to the Pelagos. Simple and to the point.
Could do without the five lines of text though.

[marcgirard]

I'd struggle not to pick the Seamaster here even though the Tudor is great.

In my opinion, the Seamaster with a black dial can from beach to tux. With the white dial, it's definitely staying the more casual/sporty realm.

[ericdejesus]

I have the black dial Pelagos and no joke, that blue is starting to tug at my heart strings! I feel like having both can be in my future.

[smilingbeard]

In the beginning of my hunt for a top level watch I was all about the Omega Seamaster but when I first saw the Tudor Pelagos I couldn’t stop thinking of it… Why did I change my mind… frankly, I feel the Pelagos is more of a tool watch than the Seamaster… Plus all Titanium doesn’t hurt either… Soon the Pelagos will be on my wrist and most probably all my other watches will just collect dust…

[grantchallinor]

I would say that, even if the Tudor cost as much as the Omega, there's a cigarette paper between both watches in terms of quality. It's really down to personal preference.
In terms of the movements, the METAS certification was announced about 6 years ago, and, to my mind, is as much a marketing exercise (as much as anything) initiated by the Swatch group for Omega watches.This is why only Omega watches are METAS certified - because this is (essentially) an Omega certification done "independently" through METAS. Hence, why would any other brands want/be able to do the same.
Brands like Omega, Rolex and Tudor usually test their watches above and beyond COSC level anyway.

[TheDrewski]

Love my 300m. I’ve got the blue and I’ll never get rid of it. Brilliant construction and movement and I really appreciate Omega as a brand. The Tudor is great but I’ve got to pick the Omega for this one