WTF Happened On Scary Island? | An investigation into RHONY's most iconic cast trip

Before Kim called Eileen a beast in Amsterdam, before Kenya twirled while exclaiming she was "gone with the wind fabulous," there was Scary Island, the infamous trip the Real Housewives of New York took in season 3. From turtle time, to Johan face, to Al Sharpton, this trip thrust oodles of moments into the housewives hive mind. Plus, we've gotta wonder: what was going on with Kelly Killoren Bensimon? So come with me as we dive all the way into the infamous Scary Island.

Social Media

Keywords
real housewives of new york
scary island
rhony
kelly killoren bensimon
bethenny frankel
ramona singer
sonja morgan
alex mccord
jill zarin
luann delesseps
the countess
money can't buy you class
rhony
real housewives of orange county
real housewives of atlanta
real housewives of new jersey
real housewives of miami
real housewives of beverly hills
real housewives of dc
real housewives of potomac
real housewives of salt lake city
real housewives of dallas
real housewives of dubai
RHOC
RHOA
RHONJ
RHODC
RHOBH
RHOM
RHOSLC
RHOP
RHODBX
RHODUBAI
WWHL
watch what happens live
andy cohen
real housewives cast trips
what happened to kelly on rhony
scary island
rhugt
real housewives ultimate girls trip
rhony legacy
real housewives of new york legacy
real housewives of new york legacy ultimate girls trip
rhugt legacy

[jo_jo_jo]

The fact you don't even need images because I can recall exactly what video goes with what quote is hysterical. Lord, have mercy of me 🤣🤣🤣

[EternalOptimist]

"...by this point, Kelly's proven that her interpretation of events often diverts from everyone else's." is the nicest/kindest way to say delusional. Thank you for your work :D

[Whatastorymark]

My favorite quotes from Scary Island: “Lay off? Oh she’s crazed”. “This is free to be, you and me, 1979”

[dennischristopher]

Jealousy was a huge factor in Kelly's insanity, but I think the fact that Bethenney didnt cower to her made her lose it. Bethenney calling her Madonna was probably the first time someone called Kelly out.

[brk]

I got here as soon as I could. *Jill voice*

[xakwonthejawn]

Next do a WTF HAPPENED in Bermuda on SLC… Amsterdam on BH… Cayman Island on Potomac… and so forth ! Great video

[IdonotwantaUtubename]

I feel in love with Sonja during this trip. The way she read the situation correctly.

[TheRealMaltus]

Scary Island is up there with Stonehenge, the Amber Room, UGT Morocco, Area 51 and all of those other big mysteries of our world!

[zdyjcko]

I don't even need the video clips. I'm such a RHONY fan and I hear them, and I can already picture the scene in my head LOL

[prestonpfeiffer]

Kelly was the pseudo “star” of these episodes but Jill’s AW YOU?” is the comedic timing that sitcoms are made of 😂😂😂😂

[posleylepex]

To this day I think Kelly confused Johnny Cochran’s quote with Jack Nicholson’s quote while also mixing up Johnny Cochran and Al Sharpton
it’s the only thing that makes the most confusing sense to me 😂😂

[ellisnichols]

you are my New York Times. needed this.

[darchocla]

Truly the greatest 3 consecutive episodes in housewives history in my opinion.

[danield]

I'm holding space for this video.

[guacamoledreams]

When the world needed her most, she came back with this gem ❤

[eraldmurati]

It’s the way I can distinguish your voice from when your just talking and reading from a script bc I’ve literally seen every video and heard every podcast I love your content so much 😭

[dardarduck]

jill being from ny is what makes her pronounce "mario" that way. my name is daria and my parents are both from ny/nj and they pronounce it a similar way. i thought it was normal until i moved out of the area lol

[robertvargas]

Absolutely worth getting the patreon video or subscription as the video editing is elite and definitely helps illustrate the top tier commentary!!!

[soyalexpop]

Yesss love your videos. BTW don’t know if it will work with copyright but you can try to put a still of the video over the video with less opacity so you can do something about copyright strikes, I’ve seen some Drag Race recaps do that

[brandoniswhoiam]

To quote Denise Richards: “Bravo, Bravo… fucking Bravo!“