which would you choose?

[bekarockygirl]

I like the brown. The brown makes your makeup look more natural.
You are beautiful; both looks look very good on you.

[suzannesteele]

Both look beautiful, but very similar. Brown is usually more impactful for blondes or people with lighter hair. But for us dark haired baddies, black usually makes the most impact. 😊❤

[vickihammons]

I see a difference. The brown looks softer. They both look good on you, IMO I've always been a black mascara person, as well but I do try different colors, periodically.

[aixac]

I prefer brown for natural looks and black for full glam.

[vintagelove]

I had never seen brown mascara before, but I actually like it better 😮

[jordynmorey]

It’s very subtle but I can tell the difference. I like the black mascara best on you 😊

[soniacordero]

You can see the difference on camera. I like the brown more but they both look nice & make your eyes look big, which highlights them more.

[kimberlysmiles]

I see the difference but honestly you are gorgeous! Which ever one you gravitate more to and feel the best in IS the one you look better in ✨

[Monica_MMO]

There is not much difference, however, I would definitely use the brown during the day with minimal make-up, and leave the black for nights out.

[RebeccaJackson-ue]

Black definitely, it gives a lot more volume to the eye ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[AnandaJain]

As a designer I can tell the difference in subtlety; brown mascara is definitely suiting you way better!

[ADbabe]

I'm usually 100% in on the black, but the brown softens your gaze and really makes your whole face more gentle and glamorous. New makeup look with the brown mascara, please!!❤🤩

[vthe]

Both are great but if you want more of a natural vibe then go for brown. Black makes your eyes pop so it’s good for other days.

[el]

Maybe brown for daytime and black for evening. Either, or both gorgeous! 😊

[ramyakamakshi]

Both look good on ur eyes. glam look black n natural look brown.

[laurenz.]

Love the brown! The brown makes your brown eyes pop! ❤

[lynnwhite]

I personally love the black on you… I myself do wear brown mascara sometimes when the eye look calls for it (I have light skin and blue/grey eyes)… but, brown shows up on my complexion more than on you I think. Girl… you know what looks good on you and what you like❤ forget all the “Karen’s” out there who think they know best about everything, and do your magic your way❤❤

[maribetcarrion]

The YSL brown mascara I find is the most noticeably brown. Maybe you’d see more of a difference with that particular one. I use it and love it 🤎

[theaondracawley]

The brown is better for natural everyday makeup and the black mascara is better for more glammed up look.

[yaaasantewaadaughterofzion]

I like the brown for every day. Black for dress up