Old Captain America Watched the Avengers This ENTIRE Time

Sound plausible?

Fans of the Marvel Cinematic Universe know that Steve Rogers is one of a kind. . .or is he? This hero experienced time travel at numerous points during “Avengers: Endgame,” and we saw him co-existing less than peacefully with his past self at the Battle of New York. So were there multiple versions of Captain America existing simultaneously on the MCU timeline? Some fans seem to think so, and even the writers confirmed that’s what they were going for. Even if he stayed in the background while his crime fighting friends saved the day again and again, we’ve still seen evidence of his existence thanks to Peggy Carter. Was Steve Rogers the mysterious husband we learned about in “The Winter Soldier?” We’ll go over the evidence supporting this theory and how this hero could have lived knowing what was going to happen with the Mad Titan Thanos in the future. Old Cap may have gone on quite the journey without ever leaving his primary timeline or informing any of his friends.

What do you think about the legitimacy of this particular fan theory? Do you think there were really two versions of this legendary hero this whole time or is that just way too far-fetched for you to believe? Let us know what you think in the comment section and don’t forget to click on the subscribe button and turn on your notifications for more new videos from us here at CBR.

Our Social Media:

Our Website

Written by: Nomde Plume
Narrated by: Joseph Delaney
Edited by: Matthew Weinstein

[jschang]

He learned how to be invisible from drax. He was there the whole time. He just didn't move so you couldn't see him.

[theguyfromwalgreens]

Am I the only one that wants to see the interaction that Cap & Red Skull have when he returns the Soul Stone?

[Oatsyx]

How is this even a question, who do you think was throwing his shield back constantly?

[jonathanramirez]

I feel this has a connection with Black Widows adoptive dad. He did mention that he fought Captain America at one point and then someone else said he was in the ice (which he was).

[shortstickfights]

It will be hilarious if all those stan Lee cameos was actually post endgame Steve in disguise

[bathogproductions]

He knew what happened in endgame and didn’t spoil it, what a great guy

[johnypanta]

Just pitching ideas here. I wouldn't mind a series showing Steve's journey to return the stones. Like WandaVision!!!

[DavidWRyan]

It makes sense, Peggy, being agent, was good a keeping secrets and she could have easily created a new identity for Steve. I agree that it must have been hard to let history happen without interference but Cap understands strategy and sacrifice to achieve the final outcome.

[leophoenix]

Honestly, I don't really care about how many caps there were. I'm just happy that Steve and Peggy got to have their dance, and grow old together.

[dpc]

So when the two Captain America’s were fighting, a third may have been watching.

[anchitmahajan]

The real reason way Steve Rogers didn't alter the timeline by changing the events may be because what he quoted in "Avengers Age of Ultron" while quarreling with Tony Stark about consequences he quoted: "Every time someone tries to win a war before it starts, innocent people die. Every time."

[jasonb]

His return to the past to live out his life with Peggy was his idea of retirement, imo. He knew their was another him out there and knew how things would go, so he had no reason to get involved a second time.

[steevysleepy]

Fans: He was in the mcu this whole time!

Marvel: He was? I mean.... he was, yes, he was there the whole time, yes!

[gerbillover]

Young Steve: *kisses Sharon*
Old Steve behind a pillar: *faceplam*

[HeyLittleBitty]

Captain America after getting married: “I can do this all night”

[griffxzero]

Watched Black Widow last night and a line from the Red Guardian struck me. When he was arm wrestling he said in 1986 or something along those lines he fought a great battle with Captain America, the guy he was sitting with noted that Captain America was still on ice at that time. Leading me to believe he had fought with the Captain after he had returned to the past and was living his life with Peggy.

[jackthefrog]

Dude, I want at least a miniseries showing cap's life with Peggy

[dsprmusic]

Imagine that the old man in Avangers 1 (who stand up against Loki in Germany) was actually Cap.. 😶

[danielfalcao]

Have you ever thought that in 50 years we are gonna be able to see how accurate was this CGI aging on Chris Evans?

[vinicioreyes]

now thanks to Loki, I think I believe this theory cause the TVA said what they did was supposed to happen so that would include steve going back to Peggy. So I do believe Steve was Peggy's husband the whole time and that him going back to her was always supposed to happen to not make a branched timeline.