Black Pearl VS Flying Dutchman VS Queen Anne's Revenge VS Silent Mary-(POTC:Battle of the ships.)

Pirates of the Caribbean: Battle of the ships

Which will win ?

Black Pearl ?
Flying Dutchman ?
Queen Anne's Revenge ?
Silent Mary ?

Please write to comments !!

*** The Dutchman must have a captain !
*** Part of the crew , part of the ship !

[_jhex]

Dutchman: Forward Triple cannons
Queen Anne's: Forward Flamethrowers
Silent Mary: Forward Devour ships
Pearl: Forward

[IcedCat]

Flying dutchman: a submarine that can also summon the kraken

Silent mary: can go on top of other ships to destroy them

Queen anne's revenge: can shoot fire and burn ships

Black pearl: *s p e e d*

[MrFool-rmnu]

Contenders and Characteristics (IN PRIME CONDITION)

The Black Pearl (cursed state)
-Fast with the wind
-Nimble
-Ability to create a mist to escape into, as is shown in POTC 1
-Commanded by cursed mortals (cannot die, but can still be physically broken)

The Flying Dutchman
-Immortal
-Fast against the wind
-There is always a Capatin
-Has the blessings of the goddess, Calypso
-Ability to summon the Kraken
-Ability to submerge underwater forever
-Guardian of the sea
-Commanded by cursed crew, forced to be loyal (part of the crew, part of the ship, absolute control over crew with the sole exception of Bootstrap Bill Turner)

Queen Anne's Revenge
-Specializes in black magic
-Ability to shoot fire
-Unbeatable in onboard crew battle
-Commanded by mortals and zombified deck masters (threat of mutiny, may or may not be successful as can be seen with Jack in POTC 4)

Silent Mary (cursed state)
-Durable
-Specializes in close range combat
-Ability to bite and tear into enemy ships
-Pet undead sharks
-Commanded by undead crew (can walk on water as if it were solid ground)

Winner: Thr Flying Dutchman

Explanation:
-The Black Pearl did not win, no. Jack Sparrow did. It just happened to be his ship. It was fast and nimble, perfect for escaping, which is a match for Jack's personality. That's why he's always fought for it. It was also destroyed by the Kraken along with a betrayed Jack Sparrow as is in POTC 2.

-Queen Anne's Revenge is strong in frontal attacks and onboard combat and that's it. The Black Pearl can out manuver it and attack it from behind.
Silent Mary is not affected by fire and its crew cannot be killed by sword or fire.

-Silent Mary is a strong ship, but it has no cannons whatsoever after it was destroyed at the Devil's Triangle. Therefore absolutely no long range attacks.

-The Flying Dutchman has proven itself the be the representation of the sea. It was blessed by the sea goddess herself. Should Captain Jack Sparrow not exist, the Black Pearl would have fallen against the Flying Dutchman. Queen Anne's Revenge is a strong contender, but let's be honest, the Dutchman can always sumberge while Revenge sticks out like a sore thumb. Plus, come on... Kraken. And finally, the undead ship. Silent Mary is strong and durable but the Dutchman can heal itself to full health if it ever gets damaged. The Dutchman can also keep their distance as it is the faster of the two, and attack from afar. The Silent Mary will sink. It's just a matter of how long it will take. Plus, the Captain of the Dutchman guides the dead into the other world. And cursed they may be, an undead crew is still dead. And KRAKEN!!!

[ramzanmelethil]

Flying Dutchman is best but at the end black pearl is on sail

[thefoxter]

Silent Mary: *Goes above Flying Dutchman
Flying Dutchman: *Sink no jutsu
Silent Mary: *Nani?!*

[jdjgaming]

Black Pearl:
*Speed
*Immortal Crew
*Smart Captain

Flying Dutchman:
*Kraken
*Immortal Crew
*Powerful Cannons
*Unsinkable
*Can go underwater

Queen Anne's Revenge:
*Fire Breathing
*Snake Ropes
*Zombified Crew
*Triton's Sword (Can curse ships)

Silent Mary:
*Immortal Crew
*Can sink ships easily
*Undead Sharks and Crows

P.S I don't know who will win but my favorite is the Black Pearl.

[monteiperier]

Who would win?

The captain of the flying dutchman, an immortal ghost ship which can go underwater, who got bested by Jack Sparrow

The captain of the Silent Mary, an immortal ghost ship which has destroyed fleets worth of pirate ships along with a disciplined crew, who got bested by jack sparrow

The captain of the Queen Anne’s Revenge, a big powerful ship with a legendary captain and zombies on board, who got bested by Jack Sparrow

The ship of Jack sparrow, the Black Pearl

[thomaselliott]

Black pearl: can sail away
Flying Dutchman: can’t sink, can summon the kraken, can summerge underwater
Flying Mary: can go on top of ships to sink

[latervader]

The Flying Dutchman for sure. You can't exactly sink such a ship...

[aeureus]

So basically, you're comparing:

- *I'm Fast af Boi, *
- *Immortal Submarine, *
- *Hell's Kitchen, and*
- *Legit Sea Food.*

I wonder which would win :O

[gOd_Marquitus]

I’m wondering how the dying gull will defeat all this ships...

[jacktheripper]

I think the Ducthman wins because none of the other ships can shoot the dutchman if it´s underwater, what makes the Ducthman almost impossible to hit. The Ducthman can suprise any of those ships by appearing at their side, shoot the cannons and dissapear again. The only disavantage of the Dutchman is that it gets slower with the wind, but it´s faster than the other ships when it travels against the wind.

In concluison:
Flying Ducthman vs Black Pearl - Dutchman wins because has more firepower and can go underwater, while the Pearl it´s just faster when has the wind on its side.
Flying Dutchman vs Queen´s Anne Revenge - Black Beard´s ship has more fire power and can cast big waves of fire, but that wont be a problem to the ducthman because it can go underwater, also the Ducthman can suprise it anytime, shoot and dissapear again. So i give the win to the Ducthman.
Flying Ducthman vs Silent Mary - Silent Mary is just a rotten ship and the only special thing that Silent Mary has is beeing able to sink ships by literaly climb on them, but that´s useless against the Ducthman because Silent Mary has to aproach the ships to do that and the Ducthman would just fire and then go underwater. So i also gives the win to the ducthman


Besides, we are not considering the most op hability of the Ducthman: summun the f*cking KRAKEN! POC Kraken is not as big as the tails and legends say, but still can attack any ship with extremly violence and sink it in minutes. So yeah, Ducthman defenitly wins this war

[Twizzly_Fizzy]

Well Black Pearl is only the Fastest ship, Queen Annes Revenge has Flamethrower and the Sword of Triton, Silent Mary is a ghost ship, The flying Dutchman is a legend of ships will sunk and two ships will battle eternaly

[ravscraves]

We all seem to forget that the pearl is crewed by the damned and captained by a man so evil that hell it self spat him back out

[morganchoat]

Flying Dutchman: can summon kraken and also is a submarine
Queen Anne's revenge: Is a flame thrower and is pilot by the most fearsome pirate of all time
silent marry: has a zombie shark army and can bite down on boats destroying any thing in its say
black pearl: I am fast boi

[ezekieltang]

I love the 3 shot cannon on the Flying Dutchman

[computerinsurgent]

Flying Dutchman is the winner, even without the Kraken. I will explain.

Queen Anne's Revenge and the Black Pearl are no match for the Dutchman. Yes the Black Pearl survived a fight with the Dutchman in POTC3, but only because the Dutchman's captain Davy Jones was killed. The Dutchman can repair itself. So if the fight would last longer, the Pearl would have sunk.

The same goes the Queen Anne's Revenge. This ship's only powerful weapon is it flamethrowers. But if the Dutchman is set on fire, it can dive like a submarine and put out the fire and repair itself. The Dutchman will then rise to the surface again and sink the damaged Queen Anne's Revenge.

And at last, there is the Silent Mary. Silent Mary's deadliest weapon is its ability to bite and break other ships like a monster. However I don't think the Silent Mary can catch up the speed of the Dutchman, plus the Dutchman could dive to avoid being bitten. Plus the Dutchman has the ability to bring the dead to the afterlife. And the Silent Mary is commanded by a dead crew.

So yeah, the Flying Dutchman is here the clear winner!

[angelrainnn]

The Flying Dutchman escorts the dead to the afterlife. The Silent Mary is a dead ship with a dead crew.

There you go, badabim badaboom.

[chilldeen]

it's sad that Queen Anne's Revenge didn't get much love here, i know it's a normal ship with no super power whatsoever, but it's an actual real life ship at least (apart from Flying Dutchman which is kind of a tale)

[enclavehere.]

All I have to say is:


“Let them taste the triple guns.”