You Won’t Believe Who Billy Eichner Follows on Instagram

Taylor Tomlinson interrogates Nico Santos, Billy Eichner, and Pete Holmes on the cringe accounts they’re following on social media.



#AfterMidnight #TaylorTomlinson #Comedy #Instagram

Watch After Midnight with Taylor Tomlinson weeknights at 12:37/11:37c, after The Late Show with Stephen Colbert, on CBS and Paramount Plus.

---
AFTER MIDNIGHT is the smartest show on television about the dumbest things on the internet. With celebrated comedian Taylor Tomlinson at the helm and a panel of guests from the worlds of entertainment, comedy, music and beyond, AFTER MIDNIGHT is a late-night comedy series about what set the internet abuzz that day with a game show feel. AFTER MIDNIGHT airs Monday through Friday, 12:37-1:37 AM, ET/PT on the CBS Television Network and streams live on Paramount+.

[PlanckRelic]

Pete and Billy have great sitcom odd-couple energy. Cracking Taylor up the whole episode

[SmellsLikeBrass]

"I think they're only following the 1%!" should have earned extra points!

[JordiVanderwaal]

"I want him to teach me how to be gay in a movie"
That was hilarious xD

[editmel]

The ACTUAL follow is gold!! Please make it a regular segment!

[ShadowAngel]

I am shocked that Nico didn’t throw in a “What’s in your wallet?”

Also, Tomlinson has really hit her stride. She’s crushing this. Excellent decision making across the board.

[marksasahara]

Great segment! Pete's belly laughs at Billy's following of the The Acting Notes, mad me LOL!, Nico's honesty was perfect and Pete's Mr. Smith Goes To Washington defense of following Billy was the best! Taylor's fake-out handshake, with a twirl was the capper!

[KurtMueller]

By far the funniest segment so far on After Midnight.

[Tonyhouse]

Pete Holmes is real life Mister PeanutButter

[TheAndOnlyGoldenboy]

I would totally watch a remake of The Odd Couple with Pete Holmes as the schlubby, messy straight guy and Billy Eichner being his anal retentive, neat freak, gay roommate.

It would SO totally work.

[BasiCitizen]

Pete and Billy are freaking hilarious together.

[khakiwakilala]

This segment is great! I think they should make it longer!!! Please keep it! The other defendants didn’t really get to cross examine so I would love if they dedicated a little time for the others to make roasts or comments! They landed on a goldmine with this one

[emilycornucopia]

I was in the audience! For the taping of this absolutely hilarious show yesterday, what creeps me out is Nico’s capital one follow on ig. There was so much cut from this where it felt like we were all laughing at Nico with the comedians making fun of him following capital one, but with editing it looks like the jokes on us because they played it off almost like a capital one comedic advertisement when it felt more like the audience and panelists were shaming him in the studio.

Unshocking news I guess, ads are everywhere and editing can really change the tone/message of a segment. Weird to actually see it all happen from the studio audience to live TV in a matter of hours. 🤯

[RenegadeReplicant]

Missed opportunity for a call back from Pete in his response to why he followed Billy Eichner "I want him to teach me how to be gay in a movie".

[bunnyfernwood]

I’m with Pete, we need more Billy on the Street!

[Chimeratear]

"Capital One: Who's in YOUR backpocket?"

[JustNardo]

This was hilarious, I wouldn't mind if it was a more permanent segment with guests haha.

[Redtail_hawk]

Can she just wear comically big shoes like why torture her in those heels?

[KunalIsTrying]

Oh my goodness best episode ever 🤣 🤣 🤣

[Tsudkyk]

I need to watch this episode, I love all the guests on this one

[enzomthethwa]

Billy looks really good now that he is not stressed out about making a movie.