RANKING BLACKPINK & TWICE & RED VELVET & MAMAMOO IN DIFFERENT CATEGORIES

[hopeflakez]

RAP
Chaeyoung>=Irene>=Yeri> Joy > Dahyun >=Wendy

So RV > Twice

[adisappointment]

this just proved how well rounded mamamoo and twice are as a group

[cosmirene]

Mamamoo definitely deserves better they are literal aces!😭

[cxli]

mamamoo aces i need to stan them because i always listening to their songs lol and they really do have good vocals

[sophiaisis]

The best basis to support this list is watching Mamamoo in concert. They did Feb 8-9 Singapore
Feb 11 Malaysia
And Feb 12 Philippines. 3 different countries in 1 week, yet in every stage they slayed with on point dancing and live vocals while ad-libbing some local languages, they got numerous praises in each show, many are even commenting that their 3 hour show was very deserving to be seen and worth the money.

[StayforOnce]

Some infants don't know the power of MAMAMOO yet!!! MAMAMOO alone can win against majority/ almost all of the ggs!!!

[Kpop_queenxx]

Mamamoo slay they are always 1 or 2 position right ranking btw

[Septemberdaysrock]

Red velvet and mamamoo are equal in vocals

[mahesawijaya]

Top 10 ok

Vocal
-Wendy
-Solar
-Wheein
-Seulgi
-Jihyo
-Hwasa
-Jeongyeon
-Nayeon
-Rose
-Mina

Rap
-Moonbyul
-Jennie
-Chaeyoung
-Hwasa
-Lisa
-Dahyun
-Irene
-Momo
-Yeri
-Jisoo
-Nayeon

Dance
-Momo
-Wheein
-Lisa
-Seulgi
-Mina
-Nayeon
-Irene
-Rose
-Hwasa
-Dahyun

Stage Presence
-Hwasa
-Jihyo
-Lisa
-Wheein
-Jennie
-Wendy
-Nayeon
-Seulgi
-Momo
-Moonbyul

[feonix]

Twice and RV are interchangeable for rap btw. Twice have better ‘rapline’ moments, while RV might have a higher average. It’s like comparing BTS and SKZ. BTS have a higher ‘average’ but SKZ have better chemistry, so either ordering is fine

[dilarabegom]

Vocals:
Proficient
Wendy(low/mid P)

AA-P
N/A

AA
Solar

A-AA
Wheein
Hwasa

A
Seulgi(high A)
Jihyo(mid A)

W-A
Jeongyeon(High W-A)
Nayeon(High W-A)
Rosie (Mid W-A)
Moonbyul(low W-A)

W
Joy (high W)
Chae (fringe low W)

U-W
Jennie, Mina
Others are just Underdeveloped/Non vocalists.

[Angel_beautiful]

Dance:
Twice
Blackpink
Mamamoo/Red velvet

[metysorse]

i stan mamamoo, but, why they better ij vocal then red velvet? /gen

[Elathea]

I would go a bit different:

Vocal:
1. Mamamoo (no discussion here, like seriously Solar, Wheein and Hwasa could be main vocalists in almost every group out there, Moonbyul is easily lead vocalist material, even main in some groups)

2. Red velvet (also an obvious choicd. Wendy is one of the best vocalists in kpop, Seulgi is an excellent lead vocalist and could be main vocalists in many groups, Joy is a solid lead vocal)

3. Twice (Jihyo is a solid main vocalist, but below Mamamoo and RV vocalists. Nayeon and Jeongyeon are great lead vocalists)

4. Blackpink (Rosie is a pretty good main vocalist, but, just as Jihyo, not comparable with Mamamoo and RV's vocalists. Jennie is an average lead, Jisoo is unfortunately a rather weak lead compared to the groups above)


RAP:
1. Blackpink (although I do think Moonbyul overall is number 1, BP's songs are much more rap focused and they have 2 solid rappers. Among kpop female rappers, they are easily above average)

2. Mamamoo (Moonbyul is a real rapper. One of the most credited female Idols, with iconic rap stages and well written verses. Hwasa was a solid lead rapper, but she doesn't rap anymore.)

3. Twice (Chaeyoung is a pretty good K-pop rappers, but the raps she is given in Twice's songs are just weak. Dahyun is a very average/below average lead and I wouldn't really call Momo a rapper)

4. Red velvet (I'm sorry but I can't bring myself to call Irene and Yeri rappers. They talk, not rap. No flow, weak verses...Imho RV's songs just DO NOT need rap...)

DANCE

1. Twice (Catchy choreographies, Momo is an excellent dancer, Jihyo is great as well, Mina and Sana are doing good too)

2. Blackpink (Lisa is phenomenal, Rosie is great. Jennie is doing a good job too. Their choreographies are rather easy, but very catchy)

3. Mamamoo (not really a dance focused group, but Wheein is a great, underrated dancer. And Solar's iconic poll dance counts too!)

4. Red velvet (Seulgi is a great dancer, Irene is a solid lead. Just as mamamoo, not really a dance focused group)

STAGE PRESENCE
1. Mamamoo (again, no discussion. All of them have INSANE stage presence, especially Hwasa and Solar. They can stay still and still hype the crowd)

2. Blackpink (Lisa has an excellent stage presence. Jennie too, but she is very inconsistent. Rosie and Jisoo are giving their best in most stages)

3. Twice (They are ok, but I don't feel super hyped up watching their performances. They do have charisma, but their performance are usually very well... staged 😅)

4. Red Velvet (I'm sorry, but I wouldn't say they have a good stage presence as a group...)

[nabiha_]

Delusional blinks in the comments bye 💀

[fooddelight]

Rap
Moonbyul (Tier 2)
Lisa (High Tier 4)
Jennie (Mid Tier 4)
Hwasa (High Tier 5)
Chaeyoung (Mid Tier 5)
Irene (Tier 5)
Yeri (Low Tier 5)
Joy (High Tier 6)
Dahyun (Mid Tier 6)
Wendy (High Tier 7)
Momo (Mid Tier 7)
Seulgi (Low Tier 7)


Rest Non Rappers

[dilarabegom]

Rap: Moonbyul : tier 2
Jennie/Lisa/Hwasa: tier 4
Chae/Irene/Yeri: tier 5
Joy/Dahyun: tier 6

[Rringthealarm]

Chae have better flow delivery and a true rapper better than Irene in terms of presence too so chaeyoung is better than Irene, dahyun is better than Wendy and momo too

[WickedSua]

Can you make mamamoo vs blackpink vs twice vs dreamcatcher vs red velvet please