Who Sang It Best?? Vocal Coach Reacts to Postmodern Jukebox Covers vs Originals

*START YOUR VOCAL JOURNEY HERE*
🎼 Weekly Private Vocal, Piano, Guitar, Songwriting, Acting Lessons

*FOLLOW ME ON SOCIAL MEDIA*

[capstang]

Haley Reinhart is a monster! Her PMJ cover of Creep is my favorite recording of that song. Great analysis, Tara!

[chriswhaley]

Agreed with you all the way. Haley Reinhart may be the best female vocalist on the planet for me and the arrangements of her two songs as well are just perfection.

[mixocrian]

The genius of this woman is beyond belief. Shes so awesome and always insightful.

[jjack-zmsr]

Hailey's"creep"is considered by many experts to be one of the top 10 singing performances of all time

[jjack-zmsr]

How could anybody not like Haley reinhart's vocals and all her expression, she has the most instantly lovable voice you will ever hear not only is she a great singer what she also knows out of perform

[zebracakez]

PLEASE do more of these! it was such a fun watch 😆

[firedoc]

Many PMJ performances are better than the originals. How Scott Bradley can rearrange songs in a way to adapt into other styles is nothing short of genius. And then bringing in some of the greatest singers, musicians, and performers just brings it all together. Some of the bests are "It's All About That Bass", the theme song from "Pinky & the Brain", and "Don't Stop Believing".

[HarryCrowe-qmiu]

I love your analysis of Haley. It’s so detailed and really gets to show just how amazing she is. I would love to see you react to her rendition of “I put a spell on you” and some of her other pmj covers in full.

[abeldiaz]

I think I've never clicked so fast on a YouTube notification before.
Here's to hoping we get more chapters to this series.

[rcinsley]

This was fun! Haley is one of the best vocalists I can remember (since the mid-50s.) I've heard the Haley/PMJ reinvention ("cover" is an inadequate description of what Scott Bradlee does with a song) of "Creep" MANY times...and every time I give it my undivided attention and watch all the way to the end.

[newtonnguyen]

I love Hailey Reinhart since American Idol. She should have been the winner that year.

[efrat]

Probably a good thing that Morgan James' PMJ covers weren't included because she dominates everything she sings.

[joyjacovino]

Haley in my opinion is “just great” and for me she can do no wrong!!

[flakedwheelie]

I really appreciate that you included Casey Abrams in this reaction. He’s by far my absolute favorite singer in PMJ.

[randomuser]

You should do more of these!! PMJ has so many good covers, like smells like team spirit, call me, side to side, and more

[George-uxzz]

I remember when you reacted to the whole song. She's amazing isn't she.

[ianesgrecia]

Just one word: Personality. The PMJ just add A LOT of personality to the songs and make it amazing

[stevebradbury]

I think the SLAYER would win just about any match up.

[DavidJCane]

Haley Reinhart's version of "Don't Speak" and Morgan James's versions of "Dream On" and "Maps" are all amazing PMJ covers. Scott Bradlee is an exceptional arranger and finds some incredible singers and musicians for his productions.

[tombodet]

Haley Reinhart is the Clear WINNER !! Love her ! She is unbelievably talented.