Overrated or Underrated? Derek Jeter Edition ⚾️

Do you think the Captain, Derek Jeter, is overrated or underrated? We asked Mets and Yankees fans ahead of the Subway Series and the responses definitely varied

Tune into The Game Day all season long for the best Insights, Stats, and Tips to make you the smartest person at the table.

Best Sports Betting Offers👇

Check us out for more below ⬇️

#TheGameDay #Shorts #MetsYankees #DerekJeter #FOTS

[seankiesling]

He has more hits than any Yankee in history...and yes thats counting Babe Ruth, Joe DiMaggio, Mickey Mantle, Lou Gehrig...etc.... he most certainly is NOT overrated when you hold that record

[pepperigefarms]

Bruh didn’t have to do the royals like that 💀

[romeothompson]

So someone who batted .300 for his career with nearly 3500 hits 260 home runs and 1300 RBIs would’ve been a nobody had he not been a yankee ? Was cal Ripken a nobody he didn’t play for the Yankees

[justsaying]

People that say he's the worst defensive shortstop just read headlines and do not actually watch baseball. He maybe lacked range but that was about it.

[mikeglenn]

6th ALL time on the hit list, top ten all time runs scored, 10 less doubles than arod, a lifetime 310 hitters, 200 plus homers and 350 stolen bases, with a 71 war. Guy was a machine in getting on base, getting in scoring position. He did it amazingly well, so much so he earned 5 rings. And please don't say he was on the Yankees, they didn't win in the 80s, and they haven't won a ws since jeter retired. He was a special player who put winning above profit.

[mikeglenn]

33 players have 3000 hits or more. That's it out of 20, 000 players, and he's 6th. It's ridiculous to say jeter wasn't special. He definitely brought that Michael jordon competitive drive to the office everyday.

[ferrari]

Everyone being interviewed is ignoring the .310 lifetime batting average.

[WillFoxy]

The guy that said a rod had a Derek heater Jersey on 😭😭😭😭😭

[OldBenKenobi]

How can someone be overrated if everyone thinks he is overrated?

[curtisthomas]

Amazing, Redsox fans gave him a standing ovation and they were rivals. Met fans in the same city hates him. That's weird.

[nevg]

I’m a Mets fan but he was not overrated! He was one of the greatest Yankees ever! As an owner, that’s another story and dissing my team! These fans are not bright at all!

[DBLoCkTV]

Based off his accolades in a Yankees uniform. He will never be underrated, he’s definitely more overrated than underrated. Still one of the best players ever to play the game. #TheCaptain

[justinhughes]

follow up ? would you have taken jeter on your team?

“YES”


smh these ppl are hypocrits to say nomar was better is a disgrace and aroid juiced

[chrisbartolini]

“Nomar was better”

Turn in your jersey, you don’t deserve to call yourself a baseball fan.

[killa]

Wsp with my guys beard it is lookin crazy

[danieltheghost]

Offensively, really good.
Defensively, dude couldn’t carry most shortstops jock strap

[bklynzcoco]

As a met fan Jeter was underrated you want to know why



He ever took steroids period enough said all those other guys ran from testing

[wilmanlopez]

I’m a yankee fan and I agree with the last guy

[coolrookie]

Why did he have to do my royals like that😭🤣

[vonyocum]

Why that dude had to call out my royals bro🤣🤣😭😭😭 there’s other bad teams too😑😂