Medieval Sword Experts React to Elden Ring

Welcome back the return of Sword Experts Drew and Paul, who are reacting today to Elden Ring. The duo will compare the Elden Ring swords with real-life swords and the main event they will use. Check the video to find out why the "double sword" wouldn't work.

Elden Ring is an action role-playing game developed by FromSoftware and published by Bandai Namco Entertainment. The game was made in collaboration with fantasy novelist George R. R. Martin, who provided material for the game's setting.
Elden Ring takes place in the realm of the Lands Between, sometime after the destruction of the titular Elden Ring and the scattering of its shards, the Great Runes. Once graced by the Ring and the Erdtree which symbolizes its presence, the realm is now ruled over by the demigod offspring of Queen Marika the Eternal, each possessing a shard of the Ring that corrupts and taints them with power. As Tarnished—exiles from the Lands Between who lost the Ring's grace and are summoned back after the Shattering, players must traverse the realm to ultimately find all the Great Runes, restore the Elden Ring, and become the Elden Lord.

#eldenring #SwordExperts #expertsreact
--------------------
--------------------
Check out some of our past videos!

Sword Experts RECREATE moves from For Honor | Experts Try

Experts React Playlist:
--------------------
Gameplay by Gamology
--------------------
Creative Commons — Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported— CC BY-SA 3.0
--------------------
Stay in the loop with us on social media!

Sword Experts REACT to Elden Ring

[OpXarxa]

Gamology showing the experts actually good footage instead of C-tier garbage roll Challenge(Impossible)

[Hackedsound]

It's nice to see a expert that actually acknowledges that it's a world with magic that might change how some things work.

[plusRpm]

Whoever played there didn‘t know the greatsword of holy order has two steps to its ash of war? Or that the basic mechanic of two-handing is a thing? Once again, impressive levels of gaming by gameology.

[Mortal]

Please, for the love of frick, two-hand the weapon.

[larry]

This kinda makes me want to see how a Fashion Designer would react to various game outfits

[Jack-yobc]

the fact the big swords weren't 2 handed annoys me way more than it should lol

[epithet]

Did the player borrow someone else's character? Because there's no way someone got that far in the game with that level of skill. (and also equipping sorceries with a faith weapon)

[thatrandomname]

They should collab and get gameplay by people who know how to play the game which would get the player's viewers here and also advertise their channel... Cause this was a video of a person who did not know two handing exists and constantly fails at their defense game

[TheDeadBrain]

I enjoy hearing what the experts have to say and all, but I feel like they are super hindered by the really shitty gameplay they are often given...

[kingofmaiars]

8:50 he is talking about the fabled "let me solo her"

The guy who soloes malena 4 man hp without getting hit.

[metwmac]

Great video!!! I would love to see more of them but more on the technical side, like showing the moveset of different weapon in a free environment and react to it without having an enemy that keeps attacking each seconds 🤣👍

[MasterKenobi]

Is There Such Thing As Crucible Knight In Real Life ? 💀

[gluttonyfang]

Gamology and their terrible armor choices, what a priceless duo lmao.

[thelion]

I love how many people in one side say "double swords are possible if the blade are shorter and the staff is longer" something i would see that it can really work and other side is "is impossible is dumb"

[anonnymous]

Why is it that every time someone shows ER fighting scenes and doesn't dual wield, they don't press the button to two hand their weapon? And than people analyzing complain that they are holding a big weapon with one hand.

YES! Because the player didn't press the button to two hand the weapon!

[afungai]

Does nobody at gamology know that you can fucking two hand your weapon in this game?

[aidenharvey]

While I very much liked their input, I find it amusing that they say "rapiers aren't for cutting" at 0:58, which is a novice misconception that "sword experts" would not say. While rapiers are PRIMARILY used for thrusting, they can still cut with deadly results; some rapiers (especially historical) have been designed to be good at both thrusting and cutting. If rapiers were not meant to cut, they would have no blade at all and all you would have is a long metal spike that could only be used to stab or as a blunt weapon.

[edi]

Why would a swept hilt be bad for a cutting sword?
There are plenty of sabers that are predominantly for slashing, which have D-guards, or 3-bar hilts. Then there are side-swords, there is the basket-hilted broadsword, the Walloon, the Schiavona, and the Claymore (the one-handed basket-hilted sword).

[damienvdm]

Blacksmith reacts to Elden Ring? Would be really interesting to hear them talk about the process and feasibility of the more intricate pieces.

[Oeraja]

Really cool how they accept the magic side.